Letters/Discussion Forums
The sin of the spies is the original 9/11
As Jews of the older generation we can only be silent bystanders and observe the rapid increase of Jewish/Israeli hatred in this country. We are literally “stuck” in this exile with nowhere else to go.
Choni Davidowitz
It is clear that our lay leaders are doing their utmost to combat this poison of anti-Zionist/Semitic sentiment and actions that are now prevalent in our society. What is equally apparent, however, is that our religious leaders are sitting back and doing nothing.
They are ignoring the obvious “message” that Hashem wishes for His children to return home. Meanwhile they are urging our youth to increase their Judaism and Torah learning, while continuing to live in exile – this in spite of Israel being open to all Jews for the first time in 2 000 years.
The question is, why are our Torah leaders ignoring the Divine call for the ingathering of Jews from the four corners of the earth? I believe the answer can be found in last week’s parsha – Shelach.
Our sages tell us that the day the sin of the spies took place on the 9th of Av when the 12 spies, who were the princes of the tribes, the most righteous of men, returned to the Jewish encampment with their message of woe and reported there was no chance in the world for the Jewish people to liberate Eretz Yisrael. The date was the original (Jewish) 9/11 – the 9th day of Av – the 11th month of the Jewish calendar, when counting from Tishrei, the 1st month of the New Year.
It’s clear that the spies did not want to come on aliyah and managed to commit the biggest sin in the Torah for which G-d wiped out the entire generation. They convinced 600 000 men to remain in the desert and forego G-d’s promise of Eretz Yisrael.
The spies did not love the Land of Israel in the way they were supposed to, but were more concerned with their own honour, knowing that in Eretz Yisrael the nation would need a new type of leadership and that they would be out of their “jobs”.
Today we have so many great and learned Torah leaders who, like the spies, are guilty of the sin of “rejecting the desirable land”. They use lame excuses and flimsy proofs to refute the words of the sages in the Talmud who said that the mitzvah of living in the Land of Israel is equal to all the mitzvot in the Torah.
Are our present Torah leaders more righteous than the spies who could not overcome their evil inclination?
What a great pity that there is no Calev and Yehoshuah among our Torah Leaders.
Golden Acres, Johannesburg